How do you review a journal article for publication?

How do you review a journal article for publication?


  1. Give positive feedback first.
  2. Briefly summarize what the paper is about and what the findings are.
  3. Try to put the findings of the paper into the context of the existing literature and current knowledge.
  4. Indicate the significance of the work and if it is novel or mainly confirmatory.

How do you become a BMJ reviewer?

To become a BMJ Open reviewer If you would like to volunteer, please register at our ScholarOne manuscript submission and review site. This process will automatically add your name, contact details and expertise to our database of reviewers. Please let us know once you have registered.

Is The BMJ a respected journal?

In the 2020 Journal Citation Reports, published in 2021, The BMJ’s impact factor was 39.890. ranking it fourth among general medical journals.

Is BMJ Open a good journal?

The overall rank of BMJ Open is 3624. According to SCImago Journal Rank (SJR), this journal is ranked 1.132. SCImago Journal Rank is an indicator, which measures the scientific influence of journals. BMJ Open is cited by a total of 26797 articles during the last 3 years (Preceding 2020).

How do you summarize a journal article?

Summarizing Papers (Making a Lit Review)

  1. Put the author’s name(s) and paper year at the top.
  2. Write 2-4 sentences on the problem the paper is trying to solve.
  3. Write 2 – 4 sentences on the solution the paper proposes.
  4. State 2 strengths of the paper.
  5. State 2 weaknesses/unanswered questions of the paper.

How do you review an article review?

5 tips for reviewing a review article

  1. Understand the journal’s requirements.
  2. Keep in mind that review articles are for a wide audience.
  3. Determine the review article’s message.
  4. Be professional and constructive in your comments.
  5. Keep your feedback consistent and content-focused.

How do I become a professional product reviewer?

Steps to Become an Established Product Reviewer

  1. Step 1: Pick a Niche.
  2. Step 2: Create a Review Website / YouTube Channel.
  3. Step 3: Write a Product Review.
  4. Step 4: Build Subscribers.
  5. Step 5: Contact the Companies.
  6. Step 6: Get More Than Free Stuff – Affiliate Marketing, Brand Deals, & More!

Are all BMJ articles peer reviewed?

The BMJ has fully open peer review for all articles which means the names of reviewers are disclosed to the author of the paper. Authors should not contact reviewers directly to discuss their reports; all queries should be directed through the editorial office.

Are all BMJ articles peer-reviewed?

Is publishing in BMJ free?

BMJ journals levy an Article Processing Charge (APC) in order to make your work open access. The BMJ, our flagship journal, charges an APC of £3,500 (exclusive of VAT for UK and EU authors) on acceptance of your research paper. Visit The BMJ’s open access page for more information.

Is BMJ free?

Originally launched in 1995, The BMJ’s website contains all The BMJ’s content back to 1840. All research articles in the archive are free; to access the remaining content, a subscription is required.